Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from listeners on serial killers, cults , cold cases and more.
Episodes
Season 1 · 4 Episodes
E1We Read Your "Or So We Thought" Emails! Amish Meth, Cat Burglars & More
23 min
E2The Kidnapping of John Paul Getty III + The Pappygate Bourbon Heist
76 min
E3We Read Your Emails! A Murder in Grandma’s Building & An Epstein Encounter
25 min
E4The Toxic Relationship of Linda Riss & Burt Pugach + The Great Emu War
80 min
No episodes match your search.
E1We Read Your Emails! The Golden State Killer, Cocaine Bear, Mothman & More
24 min
E2The My Favorite Murder 10th Anniversary Special
90 min
E3The Murder of Dorothy Donovan + Gwyneth Paltrow's Ski Collision Trial
67 min
E4We Read Your Emails! Family “Traysure” and the Live Show Puker
19 min
E5Creator/host of ERM's new pod, Two-Faced: John of God, Martina Castro
44 min
E6We Read Your Emails! Gacy Near-Miss, Mafia Banjo & Reverse Dog Kidnapping
22 min
E7We Read Your Valentine's Day Emails! Hidden Traysure & Hot Dog Love Story
25 min
E8The Heroic Story of Ruby Bridges + King of Bootleggers, George Remus
65 min
E9We Read Your Emails! Trash Parent Story, Jury Duty Behind the Scenes & More
26 min
E10Exoneration of Rubin “Hurricane” Carter + Survival Story of Lt. Leon Crane
65 min
E11We Read Your Emails! BTK Encounter & Gwyneth Paltrow Ski Trial Attendee
26 min
E12The Heroism of Lieutenant Vernon Baker and Lieutenant John R. Fox
34 min
E13We Read Your Emails! Sarah Lawrence Dorm Dad Near-Miss & A Sinkhole Story
30 min
E14We Read Your Emails! Confession Killer, Mafia Grandma & Trash Parenting
26 min
E15A Trio of Bad Bridgets + Teen Day Trading Hoax of Mohammed Islam
52 min
E16We Read Your Vacation Emails! Dad Lost at Sea & Tiger Shark Rescue
19 min
E17Costa Concordia Disaster + Beauty Magnate, Madam C.J. Walker
89 min
E18Oregon State Hospital Poisoning + World War II Hero, Marion Pritchard
59 min
E19The First Woman to Summit Mount Everest, Junko Tabei
32 min
E20We Read Your Emails! Jonas Brothers 911 Call & Online Dating Red Flags
27 min
E21Disgraceland now on ERM! Creator/host Jake Brennan joins Karen & Georgia
45 min
E22We Read Your “Disgraceland” Emails! R. Kelly, David Bowie & Taylor Swift
27 min
E23The Disappearance of Brian Shaffer + The Van Meter Visitor
71 min
E24We Read Your 4/20 Emails! Grandpa’s Illegal Weed and The Bong Squad
21 min
E25The Gilgo Beach Murders (Solved!) + The Great Diamond Hoax
67 min
E26We Read Your Emails! Ferry Captain’s Folly & Golden State Killer Encounter
31 min
E27The Great Guy Law-Time Spectacular Part II
53 min
E28We Read Your Honorary Mom Emails for Mother’s Day!
21 min
E29Trailblazing Pilot Hazel Ying Lee + The Dunbar Armored Depot Heist
61 min
E30We Read Your Emails! Sleepwalking Into a Stranger’s House & A Prom Robbery
30 min
E31Shakespeare Performances at the Broadmoor Asylum + Wisconsin Butter Fire
65 min
E32We Read Your Emails! An FLDS Encounter & A “Trash Parents” Story
28 min
E33Mental Health Rights Pioneer Elizabeth Packard + Aconcagua Mountain Mystery
84 min
E34We Read Your Emails! Fake Grandma, Train Derailment & Medieval Family Lore
23 min
E35Haing S. Ngor's Legacy and Murder + Doomed Quaker Sex Cult
74 min
E36We Read Your Emails! Dorothea Puente Connection & High School Scammer
29 min
E37The Life, Death and Legacy of Matthew Shepard
34 min
E38We Read Your Emails! Skylab Falling, Prison Dog & ’90s Money Machine
35 min
E39The Roofman Robberies + SoHo Grifter, Anna Delvey
81 min
E40Actor/Inventor Hedy Lamarr + Billie Jean King & The Battle of the Sexes
56 min
E41We Read Your Emails! Rabies at Church Camp & Two Legendary Trash Dads
27 min
E42We Read Your Emails! Scary Doll in a Wall & The Vatican City Listener
24 min
E43Buffalo Calf Road Woman, The Cheyenne Warrior Who Defeated Custer
37 min
E44We Read Your Emails! Petaluma Owls, Costco Hero & A Matthew Shepard Tribute
25 min
E45America’s First High-Profile Murder + The Kentucky Meat Shower
63 min
E46We Read Your Emails! Goat Gland Grifter & Dance Class with Liza Minnelli
30 min
E47Murder of Peter Falconio + The Chilean Goalie World Cup Scandal
71 min
E48We Read Your Emails! A Cab Ride Gone Wrong & Nana’s Birthday Cake Mixup
26 min
E49Pandora’s Box Murder + Levee Tampering and 1993’s Great Mississippi Flood
57 min
E50We Read Your Emails! Parkouring Out of Trouble & A Playground Ponzi Scheme
26 min
E51The Roslyn Embezzlement Scandal + The Scamming “Queen of Ohio”
69 min
E52We Read Your Scam Emails! 19-Year-Old Fake Doctor & Horse Pyramid Scheme
36 min
E53We Read Your Emails! Grandma’s Vape Secret & Baby Race at the Mall
22 min
E54Paul Fronczak Triple Disappearance + 1990 Michigan Wedding Sting
80 min
E55Our 500th Minisode! We Read Favorite Genres: Sassy Grandmas, Cats & More
36 min
E56The Case of Dr. John Schneeberger + The Napoleonic Hoax
60 min
E57We Read Your Emails! Transylvania University Update & Teen Forgery Scam
27 min
E58Serial Killer Michael Terry + The Sex Raft Experiment
62 min
E59We Read Your Emails! Grandpa Funeral Switcheroo & Mom’s Tinder Saga
25 min
E60“Witch Doctor” Murderer Mona Fandey + Knightsbridge Security Deposit Heist
62 min
E61We Read Your Emails! Children of the Corn & St. Paddy’s Day Snake Party
29 min
E62Trailblazing Baseball Legend Jackie Robinson
29 min
E63We Read Your Back to School Emails! Hero Teacher & Nun Slapping Story
27 min
E6425th Anniversary of 9/11: The Heroes of the 88th Floor
40 min
E65We Read Your Grandparents Day Emails! Nana’s Mafia Run-In & Grandma Prank
25 min
E66Murder of Kalinka Bamberski + Who Wants to Be a Millionaire Scandal
79 min
E67We Read Your Dolly Parton Emails! Dolly Scares 5 Yr Old & B-Day Wig Party
27 min
E68First Sleepwalking Murder Defense + Ming, Tiger of Harlem
55 min
E69We Read Your Emails! Grade School Loan Shark & Your Shameful Moments!
20 min
E70Unsolved Lane Bryant Murders + Houston’s Chicano Squad
62 min
E71The Story of Tilikum, The Killer Whale
51 min
E72The Marcos Regime and The Manila Film Center Disaster
39 min
No episodes match your search.